Private alternative investments, such as private equity, venture capital, and private debt, are a popular way for investors to diversify their portfolios and potentially achieve higher returns than traditional public markets. However, evaluating the performance of these investments can be more challenging than traditional publicly traded securities. Here are several techniques used to evaluate the performance of private alternative investments.

Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

The internal rate of return (IRR) is a common metric used to evaluate the performance of private alternative investments. It represents the discount rate at which the present value of future cash flows equals the initial investment amount. In other words, it is the rate of return an investor can expect to earn on an investment over a certain period of time.

For private alternative investments, IRR is a useful measure because it takes into account the timing and size of cash flows, including both income and capital gains. This is important because private alternative investments typically involve longer holding periods and more complex cash flow structures than traditional investments, such as publicly traded stocks and bonds.

To calculate IRR, investors need to know the timing and size of each cash flow associated with the investment. This includes the initial investment, any subsequent contributions or distributions, and the eventual exit of the investment. By discounting each cash flow back to its present value and solving for the rate at which the sum of the present values equals zero, investors can determine the IRR for the investment.

IRR is a valuable metric for evaluating the performance of private alternative investments because it provides a comprehensive view of the returns generated by an investment over time. However, investors should be aware of its limitations. For example, IRR assumes that cash flows can be reinvested at the same rate of return as the investment, which may not always be the case. Additionally, IRR does not take into account the size of the investment or the level of risk associated with the investment.

While IRR is an important tool for evaluating the performance of private alternative investments, it should be used in conjunction with other metrics and considerations to make informed investment decisions.‍

Multiples of Invested Capital (MOIC)

MOIC (Multiple on Invested Capital) is another metric used to evaluate the performance of private alternative investments. It represents the ratio of the total distributions (including both income and capital gains) to the total invested capital. In other words, it is a measure of how much money an investor received back in relation to their initial investment.

For example, if an investor put $100,000 into a private alternative investment and received $200,000 in total distributions, the MOIC would be 2x. This means that the investor received two times their original investment back in distributions.

MOIC is a useful measure for evaluating private alternative investments because it takes into account the actual amount of money that an investor has received from the investment. Unlike IRR, which focuses on the rate of return, MOIC provides a clear picture of the actual cash generated by the investment.

However, investors should also be aware of the limitations of MOIC. For example, it does not take into account the timing or size of the distributions. A high MOIC could result from a few large distributions early in the investment, even if the overall returns are not sustainable over the long term.

As with IRR, MOIC is a useful metric for evaluating the performance of private alternative investments, but it should be used in conjunction with other metrics and considerations to make informed investment decisions.

Net Asset Value (NAV)

NAV (Net Asset Value) is a measure of the value of a private alternative investment. It represents the value of the underlying assets in the investment, minus any liabilities or expenses associated with managing the investment.

In other words, NAV is the total value of the assets owned by the investment, divided by the number of outstanding shares or units. It is typically calculated on a periodic basis, such as quarterly or annually.

For private alternative investments, NAV is a useful measure because it provides a transparent and objective way to evaluate the performance of the investment. Investors can compare the NAV over time to determine if the investment is growing or shrinking in value.

However, it's important to note that NAV alone is not necessarily a comprehensive measure of the performance of a private alternative investment. It does not take into account the timing or size of cash flows, or the potential for future growth or loss. Additionally, NAV can be impacted by external factors such as market conditions or changes in regulations.

Distributions

Distributions refer to the cash flow generated by a private alternative investment that is returned to investors. Distributions may include both income and capital gains, and can be paid out on a regular basis (such as quarterly or annually) or in a lump sum at the end of the investment period.

For investors in private alternative investments, distributions are a key measure of performance. The amount and timing of distributions can provide insight into the overall health and profitability of the investment. A consistent stream of distributions can indicate a successful and growing investment, while a lack of or irregular distributions may be a red flag.

It's important to note that the amount of distributions alone is not a comprehensive measure of the performance of a private alternative investment. Other factors such as NAV, IRR, and MOIC should also be considered to make informed investment decisions.

Investors should also be aware of the potential risks associated with distributions. For example, distributions may be subject to volatility or market conditions, and may not always be sustainable over the long term. Additionally, excessive distributions may indicate that the investment is not being properly managed or that it is taking on too much risk.

Fund Performance Reports

Fund performance reports are documents that provide detailed information on the performance of a private alternative investment. These reports typically include data on key performance metrics such as NAV, IRR, and MOIC, as well as information on distributions, fees, and expenses associated with the investment.

Fund performance reports are a crucial tool for evaluating the performance of a private alternative investment. They provide investors with an objective and transparent view of how the investment is performing, and can help investors make informed decisions about whether to continue to hold the investment or to make changes to their portfolio.

When reviewing fund performance reports, investors should look for consistency and clarity in the data presented. It's important to understand the methodology used to calculate performance metrics, as well as any assumptions or limitations associated with the data.

Investors should also be aware of potential risks associated with fund performance reports. For example, data may be subject to manipulation or misrepresentation by the investment manager, or there may be external factors that impact the accuracy or reliability of the data presented.

Conclusion

It is important to note that these performance evaluation techniques may not be applicable to all private alternative investments and that other factors, such as liquidity, may also play a role in determining the performance of private alternative investments. It is important to work with a trusted investment advisor to understand the best way to evaluate the performance of private alternative investments and to develop a comprehensive investment strategy that aligns with individual financial goals and risk tolerance.

Modern x Fiduciary: At Fire Capital Management, we combine the personalized service you deserve with a modern approach to investment management you can feel. Partnering with Fire Capital is tailored, transparent, and flexible. We will develop a custom plan across traditional and alternative asset classes in both the public and private markets to meet your unique needs.

Get started on your financial journey.